Best New Hotels in Shelter Island
View all photos
From
334$/night
The Pridwin Hotel
Located nearly a 10-minute ride from the locally run aquaculture Southold Bay Oysters Farm, the 4-star The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island offers Wi-Fi in public areas and parking. The hotel features 41 rooms in a rural area of Shelter Island and lies within a 7-km distance of a place of cultural interest such as Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum.
All rooms overlook the hills.
This hotel is a great place to stay due to its waterfront location in Shelter Island. The Pridwin Shelter Island offers proximity to such natural sights as Mashomack Preserve (4.9 km) and Lavender By the Bay Farm (8 km).
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm is also approximately a 15-minute ride away.
New Hotels Downtown Shelter Island
Downtown Shelter Island has recently witnessed the establishment of new hotels that are poised to offer world-class hospitality services to guests from all around the globe. The new hotels boast of state-of-the-art facilities, architectural designs that blend in with the city's skyline, and proximity to the key tourist attractions of the city. The hotels are strategically located in the heart of the city, providing easy access to different places of interest, and are set to become a preferred accommodation choice for travelers who are visiting the city for leisure or business purposes.
View all photos
From
270$/night
Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach
Situated 3.3 km from Greenport, the boutique-style Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach Shelter Island Heights features a private art gallery. This 4-star bed & breakfast boasts a sunbathing terrace, a picnic area, and a golf course on site and guests can laze by a heated pool.
The Seven Shelter Island Heights offers rooms with an adjoining terrace and a balcony complete with an iron with ironing board and climate control. They come equipped with an electric kettle, a fridge, and glassware. Guests have access to a walk-in shower and a separate toilet, as well as bathroom comforts such as a hairdryer and dressing gowns.
The centre of Shelter Island Heights can be reached within a 15-minute walk, and natural attractions like Sylvester Manor Educational Farm are about 10 minutes' drive away. Nova Constellatio Gallery is 3.4 km away, and Southampton is 21 km from Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach.
An own beach is 16 minutes' stroll from the hotel, while Mashomack Preserve is situated approximately 15 minutes away by car. Families travelling to Shelter Island Heights will enjoy being 3.1 km from Greenport Antique Carousel.
View all photos
From
596$/night
Sunset Beach
Offering a location a 5-minute walk from Sunset Beach, Sunset Beach Shelter Island hotel offers 20 rooms. You will find a restaurant and a shopping area at this hotel.
The rooms overlook the ocean and feature such comforts as blackout curtains and air conditioning.
Guests may find Camera Obscura 3.1 km from the 4-star hotel, while Greenport is 3.4 km away. Shelter Island is also located a 10-minute ride from the property.
Nature lovers will appreciate the proximity to Crescent Beach, which is 1.6 km away. Along with other cultural attractions Railroad Museum of Long Island is nestled a 15-minute drive from this Shelter Island hotel.
View all photos
From
407$/night
Ram'S Head Inn
The 2-star smoke-free Ram'S Head Inn Shelter Island is located around 5 minutes on foot from Lower Beach and comprises 17 rooms with modern comforts. Featuring a restaurant, this Shelter Island hotel is within a 6-km distance of Greenport Antique Carousel.
Air conditioning as well as a patio and a balcony are featured in the rooms for guests' convenience. The rooms also look onto the sea.
Cultural sights in the area are Nova Constellatio Gallery (7 km) and Railroad Museum of Long Island (8 km).
Also, the Ram'S Head Inn Shelter Island is nearly a 10-minute drive from Mashomack Preserve.
New Hotels Opening in Shelter Island
Are you seeking out the latest lodgings on the scene in Shelter Island, United States? Look no further! I have sought out the recent inns and hotels to help you decide where to stay during your time in this idyllic part of the world.
For those who seek the highest quality accommodation, why not check in at the new five-star retreat in the heart of Shelter Island? You are guaranteed to be welcomed by unparalleled service and elegance throughout the entirety of your stay. With its luxurious rooms and suites, you will undoubtedly find rest and comfort in this blissful space. Plus, from live music and entertainment, specialty catering, to a rooftop pool that overlooks stunning panoramas, there is also plenty on offer to keep you entertained while staying at this trendy hotel.
Then there is the new mid-priced inn located by the waterfront. This chic accommodation offers a tranquil atmosphere and a range of tourist amenities. Expect a wide selection of restaurants in the vicinity including popular seafood eateries, plus an array of exquisite bars and bistros, as well as a wide array of boutique shops for visitors to explore. For the beach-goers, you won't have to travel far to enjoy the sand and sea; simply step outside your door and you will find yourself in an oasis of serenity.
For those looking for both affordability and style, why not consider the recently constructed budget hotel? This charming residence offers a central location and cozy atmosphere perfect for budget adventurers. Enjoy long days out by the beach, meander through nearby vintage stores and grab an array of delicious snacks from the cafe nearby. And, if that wasn't enough, there is also the tranquil garden near the entrance that can be explored while absorbing the beauty of this mesmerizing destination.
When it comes to the hottest hotels on the scene in Shelter Island, you can be sure that you won't be disappointed. Whether you seek luxury, affordability or a blend of both, this captivating US destination has something for everyone. So, don't delay - go ahead and check out all the recent lodging options on offer.
Location
Shelter Island, New York State, United States, NY 11965
Dream Locations for Your Next Trip
Contact Us